关于我们 About US 投稿/Contribute

首页> 培训>A-Level>考题> 正文

A-Level法律-法律与正义Law and Justice

新东方 2016-03-16 16:54

  Revision: Law and Justice

  Justice means different things to different people, so is very hard to define. Generally it means fairness and equality.

  Doctrines

  Rule of Natural Justice:

  This states that we must have both sides to a story, for example having witnesses come forward.

  Rule of Law:

  This states that we are "All equal before the law and in order to achieve justice we must all have equal access to the courts." i.e. we are all must follow the law so it should also be there to help us. E.g. Legal aid

  We need these doctrines because before Human Rights Act we didn't have a bill of rights such as the American Constitution.

  Theories of Justice

  Aristotle

  Said we have two types of justice, distributive and corrective

  Distributive - All benefits and burdens should be distributed fairly. This does NOT mean equal distribution of wealth, only that everything is fair. An example of this reflected in our laws are benefit laws etc.

  Corrective - If anyone tries to upset this fair distribution then their behavior should be corrected. For example courts, prison, compensation, injunctions etc.

  John Rawls

  Said that the only way to achieve true justice is if we create an 'original position' This is a group of people who are behind a 'veil of ignorance' which means that they are unaware of their social status, abilities, background, place in society etc.

  His point being that the people who make the laws have their own agenda, so you can't achieve true Justice.

  Nozick

  If you get wealth legally and fairly, then it should be yours to keep. However those who don't have any wealth shouldn't be helped. The problem with this theory is that some can't afford training for a good job.

  Marx

  He believed that the law is made to protect the middle class and their property from the working class. He thought everyone should be equal.

  The Relationship between law and justice

  Formal Justice

  These are mechanisms in place in order to try and underpin a just society. for example: Judges and Lawyers. We have Montesque's Seperation of powers, ensuring none of the 3 groups do anything unjust.

  Judges are also free from financial and political pressure. Barristers have the Cab Rank rule, to ensure everyone is represented.

  However, judges are usually from middle class backgrounds, and there is a lack of women and ethnic minorities. Trial by peers means that they have local knowledge.

  Due to the Criminal Justice Act 2003 judges can now sit on Juries, so is it still trial by peers?

  They have no legal training and often bow to media pressure. Lord Dennings said "The jury is a corner stone to a civilized society."

  Substansive Justice

  These are mechanisms we have in place to ensure a just outcome.

  Precedent

  We have stare decisis (like cases treated alike) which underpin the development of the law and it is a key to consistency. House of Lords have the Practice Statement 1966 which allows them to over turn an unjust decision. However to ensure consistency, they rarely use it. FORD (follow, overrule, reverse, distinguish) ensures that each case is treated on its own fact.

  Sentencing Guidelines

  We have varying tariffs e.g. 2-5yrs which allow pre-sentence reports, mitigating and aggravating factors to be taken into account. The victim however may argue that it is TOO fair on the defendants Life also doesn't always mean life.

  Miscarriages of Justice

  Despite the attempts to ensure justice, we do still sometimes get it wrong.

  E.g. Steven Downing was wrongly imprisoned for 26 years. Although he got £250,000 compensation because he is so institutionalized he can't pick up his life again.

  It is a very long, drawn out process in order to get someone released, however we do have the Criminal Cases Review committee who look at cases of those who are adamant that they are innocent.

分享到:
相关文章 A-Level法律
推荐

智囊分享

A-level经济学专业词汇解析

提到A-level经济学,可能很多小伙伴两眼热泪吧,尤其是想到那些常用的专业词汇的时候吧,不仅难记忆,就是理解都不是那...
A-Level作为英国高中课程大概有20门的热门课程。在申请的选课这一环节中,大部分家长和学生在选择课程的时候都很迷茫。...
很多同学咨询想去英国留学,是初中毕业后直接就读A-level课程好呢?还是到高二年级就读比较好呢?下面,主页君就这个问...
  今天兆龙留学为大家分享的是已经在英国就读GCES第一年的学生如何申请英国的A-LEVEl。一起来看看吧。   1、申请时间
  A-Level中文对于中国学生来说,自然是英国顶尖大学不怎么待见的科目。如果想要上最top的英国大学,数学、物理、经...
推荐给好友


邮箱格式错误

发表成功

您的评论将在编辑审核后发表,感谢您的参与

登录继续邮箱格式错误

没有账号? 快速注册忘记密码?

其它账号登陆:

需编辑审核